Best Roasters Reviewed

Having a delicious roast on the table, especially when the holidays are here is one of the absolute necessities that can make or break the perfect family reunion. Of course, you could use an oven. Well, what could be better than making your own roasted meat at home with your preferred choice of spices and flavoring added to the roast! The oven may not be used every day, but it will be used for those special occasions of the year, and many of the more elaborate recipes will involve some sort of even roasting or cooking. Sometimes it seems like too much of a hassle having to turn on and preheat oven when you only want to heat or cook a little food. Or if you want o roast two different foods that require different cooking times or temperatures.

Our Top 3 Picks

Oster 22-Quart
  • Oster 22-Quart
  • 5 out of 5
  • Saves 30% more time
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Rival 18-Quart
  • Rival 18-Quart
  • 4.6 out of 5
  • Large capacity
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Granite Ware Roaster
  • Granite Ware Roaster
  • 4.2 out of 5
  • Porcelain finish
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

You can do nothing or you can move with the changing times and get an electric roaster oven. Even if your current oven is perfect, even if you have the timings down perfectly, you are still going to need that oven for other types of cooking. It is basically a mini oven that sits conveniently on your kitchen bench and plugs into a power socket. They generally do everything a conventional oven does, sometimes more all while being completely portable and flexible. A good roaster oven is a valuable investment and an essential piece of kitchenware for anyone who takes their cooking seriously. Whether you’ll be hosting large dinners for family and friends during the holidays or smoking a quantity of meat for a summer barbecue, roaster ovens are an invaluable investment.

And that always raises the question of what oven to use – especially if you’re planning to cook a large turkey, ham, roast, or even a cold-smoked brisket. They need to be sturdy and strong, distribute heat well, and be versatile enough that they can be used more than once a year. They also need to be able to transfer from the oven to the stovetop for deglazing, without any hot spots or buckling over direct heat. And for optimal performance, several additional factors need to be considered as well. The size, shape, and design are all important, as is the material used in construction, and the overall weight.

Best Roasters Reviews

There are many models that flock the current cooking appliance market, so bring you a selection of the top 10 best roasters that have made waves in the current market due to their top quality and outstanding performance.

1. Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven

best roasters

Roast, bake and slow cook to perfection with the the number 1 product on our best roasters list, the Oster 22-Quart Roaster Oven which is designed with a unique, self-basting lid to keep your foods moist, nutritious and delicious. Simple to use with fool-proof results, you can serve holiday and special occasion meals that are moist, tender and delicious. Plus you can save time, energy and double your regular oven space for more efficient meal prep. With a large quart capacity, it will fit a turkey up to 26 pounds. Think about all the other dishes you can heat and cook in your kitchen oven while the turkey roasts perfectly in the Oster Roaster Oven. Plus, you’ll save 30% more time for cooking and use 36% less energy than a traditional oven.

Features:

  • 22-quart Roaster Oven roasts up to a 26 lb turkey
  • Stainless steel finish roaster oven
  • Self-basting lid saves time, heat and energy; no need to manually baste prevents heat from escaping and speeds cooking time
  • Includes removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan for fast, even heat distribution and easy clean-up; plus steel roasting rack
  • Bakes anything your regular oven would, from muffins to yeast rolls to an entire sheet cake
  • Variable temperature control dial sets roaster to cooking temperature of 150°F to 450°F
  • Saves 30% more time and uses 36% less energy than a traditional oven
  • Exterior Dimensions: Length: 23.31″, Height: 11.85″, Width: 15.67″, Weight: 15.43 lbs
  • Interior Dimensions: Length: 17.48″, Height: 6.92″, Width: 11.57″

Pros:

  • Simple to use with fool-proof results, you can serve holiday and special occasion meals that are moist, tender and delicious.
  • You can save time, energy and double your regular oven space for more efficient meal prep.
  • You can easily simmer a delicious gravy right in the roaster oven pan without hassle.
  • There’s no mess and you keep stovetop burners free for other cooking.
  • Your turkey will cook perfectly tender and moist with the Oster Self-Basting feature.
  • A specially-designed lid does the basting for you by continually re-circulating moisture, eliminating tedious, time-consuming hand-basting.
  • Enamel-on-steel roasting pan and roasting rack are both removable for easy cleanup.
  • Dial sets roaster to cooking temperature from 150°F to 450°F to roast, bake or slow cook to perfection.

Cons:

  • Temperature is not accurate.
  • Do not use turkey bags. They stick to the sides.
amazon button

2. Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven

best roasters1

Make the perfect holiday meals and special occasion dinners in the Rival 18-Quart Roaster Oven. Fill your home with the delicious smells of turkey or ham in this roaster oven and impress your friends and family with a meal that is tender, juicy and flavorful. With a large capacity, you can conveniently roast a turkey up to 22 pounds with delicious results. Plus, you’ll get more room in your kitchen oven for other dishes. The roomy design of roaster features enough space for the included removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan and steel rack. The lid of the Rival roaster oven rests delicately atop the edge and holds in the heat to properly cook your dish. In addition, this roaster cooks up to 30% faster and with up to 77% less energy than a traditional oven.

Features:

  • Large capacity is ideal for preparing holiday dinners and for entertaining
  • Extra cook space along with versatile cooking options for roasting, baking and slow cooking
  • Foods cook to moist, tender texture and delicious flavor
  • Variable temperature control dial sets roaster to cooking temperature of 150°F to 450°F
  • Doubles much needed oven space for holiday meals and entertaining
  • Saves 30% more time and uses 36% less energy than a traditional ovenᶧ
  • Includes removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan for fast, even heat distribution and easy clean-up

Pros:

  • The white Rival roaster oven creates that necessary space on your counter to help make sure your entire dinner comes together at the right time.
  • The roomy design of roaster features enough space for the included removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan and steel rack.
  • The lid of the Rival roaster oven rests delicately atop the edge and holds in the heat to properly cook your dish.
  • You save 30% more time for cooking and use 36% less energy than a traditional oven.
  • Large capacity is ideal for preparing holiday dinners and for entertaining, providing extra cook space along with versatile cooking options for roasting, baking and slow cooking.
  • Variable temperature control dial sets roaster to cooking temperature of 150°F to 450°F.
  • You won’t have to cook your bird or roast ahead of time just to make room in the oven. And when you are done, clean up is quick because the roaster pan is dishwasher safe.
  • Ideal for large gatherings, social functions, special events, or holiday entertaining.

Cons:

  • The cord is way too short.
  • It takes up a lot of space when not in use.
  • There’s no indicator light to tell if it’s on or off.
amazon button

3. Granite Ware 18-lb Oval Roaster

best roasters2

Whether you’re making the Thanksgiving turkey or traditional hams and roasts, the Granite Ware 18-lb Oval Roaster is just the thing for you. The dark porcelain surface and steel core absorb the oven’s energy and evenly distribute heat. The naturally nonstick surface contains no harmful chemicals and will not change the taste, color, or nutritional value of foods. It provides excellent heat distribution and cooks evenly. Ideally suited for a 12-pound bird or a 15-pound roast, this oval roaster boasts even heating and faster cooking times because of its unique construction. The naturally non-stick surface is highly durable even allowing you to use your metal utensils during cooking.

Features:

  • Sized for a 12 lb. bird or 15 lb. roast
  • Porcelain finish is naturally non-stick
  • Carbon steel construction for even heating and cooking
  • Dark color absorbs heat quickly for faster cooking times
  • Non-reactive finish won’t absorb food flavors, or change the color or taste of your food
  • Dimpled lid bastes food for moist meals
  • Durable finish is tough enough for metal utensils
  • Side handles for easy lifting and moving
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleanup

Pros:

  • The dark porcelain surface and steel core absorb the oven’s energy and evenly distribute heat.
  • Porcelain is fused to the steel at 2,000 degrees Fahrenheit producing a non-porous, inert glass surface that is naturally non-stick.
  • Since the glass surface is inert and will not absorb foods, the taste is not altered like it can be with other surfaces.
  • There are no PTFE’s, PFOA’s or any other chemicals to change the taste, color or nutritional value of the food.
  • It cooks faster and more evenly than other roasters and is a better value than stainless steel roasters.
  • The handles are built to hold the weight of the bird much better than a flimsy, disposable, aluminum foil tray.
  • The oval shape with side handles features a cover with inverted dimples that keep food moist from condensation replenishment.

Cons:

  • The lid does not line up with the base.
amazon button

4. Oster 18-Quart Roaster Oven

best roasters3

The Oster 18-quart Roaster Oven is designed with a unique, self-basting lid to keep foods moist, nutritious and delicious. As a self-contained roaster, it uses the steam from cooking to lock in juices, so you can serve mouth-watering, flavorful meals to guests when entertaining. It also shortens cooking time and eliminates the need for constant hand basting. It’s equipped to help make preparing your special occasion dinners easier in so many ways, including eliminating the extra work of hand-basting with a self-basting lid design. With a large quart capacity, it will fit a turkey up to 22 pounds. This is a must for holiday meals and entertaining.

Features:

  • 18-Qt Roaster Oven roasts up to a 22-lb Turkey
  • Self-Basting Lid Saves Time, Heat & Energy
  • No need to manually baste, prevents heat from escaping and speeds cooking time
  • Includes removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan for fast, even heat distribution and easy clean-up; plus steel roasting rack
  • Bakes anything your regular oven would, from muffins to yeast rolls to an entire sheet cake

Pros:

  • Your turkey will cook perfectly tender and moist with the Oster Self-Basting feature.
  • A specially-designed lid does the basting for you by continually re-circulating moisture, eliminating tedious, time-consuming hand-basting.
  • Large capacity is ideal for preparing holiday dinners and for entertaining, providing extra cook space along with versatile cooking options for roasting, baking and slow cooking
  • It Saves 30% more time and uses 36% less energy than a traditional ovenᶧ
  • The removable roasting plan with wide mouth opening provides easy access to food and fast clean up.
  • The removable rack lets you easily transfer food to serving platters.
  • This roaster oven can be used to cook or bake just about anything you would normally make in a traditional oven.

Cons:

  • The temperature dial is not accurate.
  • You must check your food as it does bake and cook faster than a regular oven.
amazon button

5. Proctor Silex 32700 Portable Roaster Oven

best roasters4

Proctor Silex Roaster Oven makes it easy to feed a crowd. Not only do this convenient roaster oven bakes, roasts, and cooks like a traditional oven, it’s also great for making popular desserts like cheesecake and pound cake. The best part, it’s portable, which makes it perfect for cooking away from home on Thanksgiving and other special occasions. Whether you’re roasting a turkey, baking potatoes, or cooking a side dish, Proctor Silex roaster oven gives you the extra cooking space you need when your main oven is busy cooking other dishes or desserts. After the meal, you can relax – Proctor Silex roaster oven have a removable cooking pan that lifts out for easy cleanup at the sink.

Features:

  • Roasts, bakes and serves
  • Fast and easy roasting
  • Increase your oven space
  • Removable pan
  • Inner material: Ceramic

Pros:

  • It features adjustable temperature settings for flexible cooking options and fits right on your countertop, greatly increasing your available oven space.
  • It comes with a removable pan for easy serving and fast cleaning.
  • The pan can be lifted easily and brought directly to the table.
  • The portable roaster oven makes it easy to prepare an entire meal at once, cutting hours out of your regular allotted cooking times.
  • Easy roasting and baking for parties and large family gatherings any time of the year.
  • This handy appliance is ideal for any cook, especially for those with small kitchens and studio apartments.

Cons:

  • Food sticks on the lining.
  • The lid slides off easily. Doesn’t fit well.
  • The metal seems cheap.
amazon button

6. Nesco 18 Quart Roaster Oven

best roasters5

Since 1932 the Nesco brand name has been synonymous with Roaster Ovens. With a Nesco Roaster Oven you can roast, bake, cook, steam, slow-cook and serve. Other than broiling, the Nesco Roaster Oven can do anything a normal oven can do but better and with less energy usage and less heat generated in the kitchen. The Roaster Oven is portable so you can make great tasting meals wherever you go. This large slow cooking system is capable of roasting a whole turkey up to 22 lbs. The Nesco 18 Quart Roaster Oven is ideal for baking cookies, cakes, pies, quiche and even whole meals.

Features:

  • 1425 watts heating element
  • Adjustable full-range temperature control to 450 degrees
  • Porcelain enamel coated steel cookwell that is dishwasher safe for easy clean-up
  • Designed for better baking and fat-free roasting
  • Turns off when the roaster reaches the desired temperature
  • Patented Circle of Heat heating element cooks from the side for moist, evening cooking
  • Resists scratching and won’t corrode, stain or chip
  • Delivers long-lasting, commercial-level performance
  • Automatic temperature control assures even, energy-efficient cooking

Pros:

  • Unique Circle of Heat construction means foods are cooked from the side, not the bottom, for more moist cooking results.
  • Single chrome steel rack includes handles for safe, easy insertion and removal of hot foods
  • The Automatic Temperature Control provides a wide range of temperature settings from 200 degrees to 450 degrees which allow you to slow cook, roast, bake, steam – as well as sear and brown foods.
  • Optional Buffet Serving Kit turns this unit into a portable Buffet Table, great for serving 3 appetizers or meal items at once.
  • The cookwell is removable and the entire unit is easy to handle, easy to clean, and easy to store.
  • Removable steel rack has easy lift out handles for safe, easy insertion and removal of hot foods.
  • The porcelain enamel coated steel cookwell is specially designed for the demands of preparation and volume cooking.

Cons:

  • The oven gets really hot on the outside.
  • Does not fit standard dishwashers and household sinks.
amazon button

7. Gibson Home 16-Inch Oval Roaster Pan

best roasters6

Host family dinners and other fun events in your home with the Gibson Home 16-Inch Oval Roaster with Lid and Rack. Get ready for the holidays with this stainless steel roaster pan that is 16 inches at its widest point and can fit most large turkeys. The Top Roast oval roaster with included rack and lid set comes in stainless steel and features a non-stick interior. Prepare juicy and tender pot roasts with this convenient roaster pan with lid and rack. This oval roaster is constructed of durable stainless steel with a mirror finish for years of enjoyment.

Features:

  • Includes 16-inch oval roasting pan, a lid and an interior rack
  • Non-stick interior for easy cleanup
  • Crisp and clean stainless steel
  • Ideal for holiday dinners with ham, roast or turkey

Pros:

  • It’s constructed of heavy-duty stainless steel for durability and years of enjoyment.
  • The non-stick interior makes it easy to clean, and it has handles for easy removal from the oven.
  • It is resistant to corrosion and will last you for many dinners to come.
  • The handles are also large enough to accommodate oven mitts.
  • The pan and lid have a mirror finish so no scratch cleaning sponge or brush will be required to maintain the finish.
  • The lid fits well and is vented, which is something you don’t find with many higher priced roasters.

Cons:

  • The lid doesn’t sit very securely.
  • The roasting rack sits a little less than a half inch from the bottom of the pan.
amazon button

8. Cook N Home Nonstick Turkey Roaster

best roasters7

If you’re looking for a quality nonstick turkey roaster then the Cook N Home Nonstick Turkey Roaster fits just right in. It comes with a rack, measures 16 inches by 12 inches, and holds up to a 25-pound turkey. Nonstick coating makes food release and cleaning easy and heavy-gauge aluminum is super conductive for even heat distribution to prevent hot spots. The heavy gauge aluminum construction provides the roaster with superb heat conductivity for even distribution of heat. The cooking space comes with special nonstick coating which makes cleanup a breeze. The generous large roasting space provides sufficient cooking for accommodating up to 25 pounds turkey for large family gatherings.

Features:

  • Nonstick coating made food release easy and clean easy, durable 2 coating system is PFOA free
  • Large size roaster pan hold up to 25lb turkey 16-inch x 12-inch x 3-inch
  • V-shaped rack allows for even browning of meat and collecting juices during roasting
  • Solid cast handle is riveted on side of for secure grip
  • Not for Induction Cooktop. Works on all type cooktop include Gas-Electric-Hot Plate-Halogen-Ceramic
  • Oven safe to 450F and Dishwasher safe

Pros:

  • Nonstick coating makes food release and cleaning easy and heavy-gauge aluminum is super conductive for even heat distribution to prevent hot spots.
  • V-shaped rack allows for even browning of meat and collecting juices during roasting.
  • The durable 2-coat system is PFOA-free.
  • The generous large roasting space provides sufficient cooking for accommodating up to 25 pounds turkey.
  • The roaster is safe up to 450 degrees and is also dishwasher safe making cleanup a breeze.
  • It’s equipped with solid caste handle firmly riveted for secure grip.

Cons:

  • Not compatible with induction stovetops.
  • The tray isn’t easy to clean.
  • Handles stick out a little.
amazon button

9. Magnalite Classic 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster

best roasters8

Make delicious, slow-cooked meals the classic way with the Magnalite Classic 18-Inch Oval Covered Roaster. The sleek retro styling and durable cast construction is ideal for cooking tasty roasts, stews and casseroles. This Magnalite roaster is constructed of professional grade, hand-cast aluminum that provides durable, long-lasting service. The cookware comes with a rack for keeping roasting food elevated and a heavy, tight-fitting lid that helps retain heat and keeps all the juices in, ensuring retention of mouth-watering flavor for steaks and more. Manufactured to the highest culinary standards, this heavy aluminum roaster offers unsurpassed cooking performance. Busy cooks will appreciate the self-basting cover.

Features:

  • Professional grade, hand-cast aluminum
  • Thick base won’t warp
  • Heavy, domed lid locks in moisture, transfers heat from side walls and facilitates convection-style heating
  • Even finish eliminates hot spots
  • Includes meat rack
  • Permanent side handles never become loose
  • Handles and knobs are oven-safe to 350 degrees

Pros:

  • This Magnalite roaster is constructed of professional grade, hand-cast aluminum that provides durable, long-lasting commitment.
  • The cookware comes with a rack for keeping roasting food elevated and a heavy, tight-fitting lid that helps retain heat and keeps all the juices in.
  • The dome-shaped design of the lid transfers heat from side walls and facilitates convection-style heating, letting ingredients cook faster and more thoroughly.
  • The cast-aluminum roaster features permanent side handles that will never loosen with use.
  • High sides make the roaster suitable for braising, stewing, and slow cooking with liquids.
  • Heavy domed lids lock-in moisture, transfer heat from the vessel side wall, and help facilitate convection style heating.
  • Permanent side handles never get loose even after repeated use.

Cons:

  • The lid doesn’t fit.
  • It’s only big enough for small roasts.
amazon button

10. Nesco 3-Piece Buffet Server Kit

best roasters9

Turn your Nesco Roaster Oven into a food warmer with these 3 buffet server pans held in by 2 brackets. The Buffet Kit has three buffet server pans that hold up to 3 different dishes and are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning. It has 2 3/4 quart capacity and divider plates with nonstick surface. The buffet features durable aluminum construction that provides even heating and can be used with virtually all Nesco 18 Quart roaster ovens. With the Nesco Roaster, the pans have superior even heating so their suitable for all types of food and make for easy serving. It’s perfect for appetizers, buffets and entertaining.

Features:

  • Turn your Nesco Roaster into a food warmer
  • Ideal for appetizers, buffets, and entertaining
  • Includes three 2-3/4 qt non-stick buffet pans and 2 brackets
  • Durable aluminum construction provides even heating
  • Divider plates; nonstick surfaces; dishwasher-safe

Pros:

  • The divider plates keep pan in place and allow pans to fit virtually all Nesco 18 qt Roaster Ovens.
  • With the Nesco Roaster, the pans have superior even heating so their suitable for all types of food and make for easy serving.
  • Pans are completely coated with non-stick inside and out for super easy cleaning and all pieces are dishwasher safe.
  • The buffet features durable aluminum construction that provides even heating.
  • Ideal for large gatherings, social functions, special events, or holiday entertaining.

Cons:

  • The pan can fall into the pan below if you aren’t super careful when stirring items.
  • The oven gets really hot on the outside.
  • The kit only fits a few models.
amazon button

Decision Time

Your roaster oven is likely to be something that is used often – weekly if not every day or so. Therefore, something that is so often used and that plays such an integral part in preparing your regular meals should be of high quality and meet your needs. The general rule of thumb is to consider your electric roaster oven to be exactly the same in every way to your conventional oven. There may also be accessories such as additional racks and pans that can be purchased separately which can effectively add functionality.